OP-ED
October 21, 2026

OP-ED FROM THE CERTIFIED TRADING CARD ASSOCIATION

Nearly $1 Million in Stolen Trading Cards: A Wake-Up Call for Our Industry

We cannot continue treating these incidents as isolated shipping problems. They are industry trust and consumer protection issues.

By Nick Jarman, Founder & CEO of Certified Trading Card Association

Nearly $1 Million in Graded Cards Stolen

The recent theft of nearly $1 million in PSA-graded trading cards from a FedEx truck in Santa Ana, California, should serve as a wake-up call for the entire trading card industry.

On October 13, thieves reportedly stole two pallets of graded trading cards and additional packages from a third pallet, with initial losses estimated at $963,000. These weren't simply packages being transported. They represented years of collecting, significant financial investments, and, in many cases, irreplaceable pieces of personal history.

My first thoughts are with the collectors affected. While financial compensation may help recover some of the monetary loss, it cannot always replace the sentimental value, time, and effort invested in building a collection.

Are We Doing Enough?

This incident raises a much larger question: Are we doing enough as an industry to protect the collectors who trust us with their valuable assets?

PSA has reportedly deactivated the certification numbers associated with the stolen cards, notified marketplace partners, and begun working with affected customers on compensation. Those are important steps, but we must also examine what can be done to prevent incidents like this from happening in the first place.

Grading companies across the industry need to reevaluate their shipping security protocols, carrier relationships, chain-of-custody procedures, insurance protections, and safeguards surrounding high-value shipments. When collectors entrust companies with cards worth thousands, sometimes hundreds of thousands of dollars, protecting those assets must remain a top priority from the moment they are received until they are safely returned.

We cannot continue treating these incidents as isolated shipping problems. They are industry trust and consumer protection issues.

Why the Global Trading Card Registry Exists

This is also precisely why the CTCA established the Global Trading Card Registry (GTCR).

The GTCR has been developed as an independent trust infrastructure for graded trading cards, giving collectors, dealers, marketplaces, and other industry participants an additional resource to identify cards reported lost or stolen.

Through a simple Trust Check, buyers and sellers can review available registry information before completing a transaction. While no registry can guarantee recovery or prevent every fraudulent sale, broader adoption of independent verification tools can make it more difficult for stolen collectibles to circulate unnoticed.

The Industry Must Grow Together

I believe grading companies, marketplaces, shipping providers, and industry organizations must work together to establish stronger preventive standards, improve information sharing, and build meaningful protections for collectors.

The trading card industry has experienced extraordinary growth. Now our commitment to security, accountability, and consumer protection must grow alongside it.

At the CTCA, we believe the hobby is worth protecting. Incidents like this remind us exactly why.

Before You Buy, Trust Check.

WWW.THEGTCR.COM

Nick Jarman

Founder & CEO

Certified Trading Card Association

Safer. Smarter. Stronger.

01Advocacy
02Education
03Standards & Trust
04Community & Growth