OPINION | TRADING CARD INDUSTRY
Innovation Is Not the Enemy: Stop Painting Digital Repacks With a Broad Brush
By Nick Jarman, Founder & CEO, Certified Trading Card Association (CTCA)
I've watched the conversation surrounding digital repacks, digital rips, and technology in the trading card industry become increasingly one-sided. And quite frankly, I believe we need to have a much more responsible and balanced discussion about where this industry is heading.
A recent Sportico article, Digital Card Rips' Worst-Case Scenario? 'Slot Machines for Kids', raises questions about the intersection of digital collectibles and gambling.
Those questions deserve attention. Consumer protection matters. Transparency matters. Responsible business practices matter.
But what concerns me is the growing tendency among some commentators to paint an entire category of innovation with the same negative broad brush.
That is not only unfair to the companies working to build legitimate businesses and improve the collecting experience. In many respects, I believe it is irresponsible.
And it risks doing real damage to an industry that has tremendous opportunities ahead of it.
Let's Not Confuse Innovation With Irresponsibility
The trading card industry has evolved continuously throughout its history.
We've gone from tobacco cards to bubble gum packs, from neighborhood hobby shops to online marketplaces, from traditional auctions to livestream selling, and from handwritten price guides to real-time market data.
Every generation has introduced new ways to collect, buy, sell, trade, and engage with the hobby.
Digital repacks are another evolution of that experience.
The technology allows collectors to discover cards, purchase products, reveal their contents, manage collections, and potentially take possession of physical assets through an experience that would have been difficult to imagine just a decade ago.
And there are legitimate benefits.
Greater accessibility. More efficient transactions. Improved inventory management. Digital ownership records. Secure vaulting. Global participation. New opportunities to bring collectors into the hobby.
Are there risks? Absolutely.
Are there companies that may operate without sufficient transparency or consumer protections? Of course.
But those concerns are not exclusive to digital repacks. They can exist in traditional repacks, physical breaks, online marketplaces, auctions, and virtually every other segment of the collectibles business.
The problem isn't the technology. The problem is how technology is used, how businesses operate, and whether consumers are adequately protected.
Those are very different conversations.
We Cannot Apply One Standard to Digital Products and Another to Traditional Collecting
For generations, collectors have purchased sealed trading card products without knowing exactly what they would receive.
The excitement of opening a pack, discovering a rare card, or finding something unexpected has always been part of collecting.
That doesn't automatically mean every randomized digital product operates identically to a traditional sealed pack. Some digital models introduce features such as instant buybacks, rapid repeat purchases, and different financial incentives that deserve independent examination.
But it also doesn't mean every product incorporating a digital reveal should automatically be characterized as gambling.
We need to examine the actual mechanics of the product.
What is the consumer purchasing? Is there a real, identifiable collectible behind the transaction? Is ownership clearly established? Can the customer take possession of the physical card? Are the terms transparent? How are values determined? Are there appropriate safeguards?
These questions matter far more than whether someone opens a pack with their hands or taps a screen.
And while legal classifications ultimately belong to lawmakers, regulators, and the courts, the industry has an obligation to approach these issues with facts rather than assumptions.
A digital interface does not automatically make a legitimate collectible transaction illegitimate.
Nor does attaching a physical collectible automatically eliminate every consumer protection or legal concern.
Both things can be true.
Responsible Criticism Is Necessary. Broad Condemnation Is Not.
I have no issue with journalists, collectors, regulators, or industry participants raising legitimate concerns.
In fact, we should welcome scrutiny.
But there is a significant difference between identifying specific practices that may harm consumers and suggesting that an entire emerging business model is inherently problematic.
When we use the most extreme examples to characterize an entire category, we risk creating a narrative that overlooks responsible operators, discourages investment, and undermines meaningful progress.
There are businesses investing substantial resources into technology, infrastructure, security, fulfillment, and better collecting experiences.
Those businesses deserve to be evaluated on their individual practices.
They should not be presumed irresponsible simply because they operate in a new segment of the market or because their technology resembles features found in another industry.
We should be asking which companies are getting it right, which practices need improvement, and how the industry can establish expectations that protect collectors without unnecessarily limiting innovation.
That is how industries mature.
Not through fear. Not through sweeping generalizations. And certainly not by treating every new business model as a threat before we fully understand it.
The Answer Is Standards, Not Stagnation
This is precisely why I believe independent industry standards are so important.
At the Certified Trading Card Association, our mission has always been to help build a safer, smarter, and stronger hobby.
That mission is not about standing in the way of innovation.
It's about helping create an environment where innovation and consumer trust can coexist.
For digital repacks and similar products, I believe the industry should be working toward meaningful expectations surrounding:
Transparency: Clear product descriptions, pricing, potential outcomes, and disclosures regarding how products are assembled and distributed.
Authenticity and ownership: Verifiable collectibles, accurate representations, and clearly defined ownership and redemption rights.
Fairness: Documented procedures for randomization, inventory controls, and the integrity of product distribution.
Consumer protection: Appropriate age safeguards, responsible purchasing practices, accessible dispute resolution, and clear terms.
Accountability: Meaningful expectations for operators and a willingness to address practices that undermine consumer trust.
These principles should apply based on the risks and mechanics of the product, not simply whether the transaction takes place digitally or physically.
The CTCA has already recognized the importance of developing standards for repacks and surprise products. That work becomes even more relevant as technology continues to reshape the industry.
We should be bringing operators, collectors, technology providers, legal experts, and other stakeholders together to help establish a responsible framework.
Not deciding in advance that innovation itself is the problem.
We Should Be Encouraging Responsible Companies to Lead
I want to see companies investing in this space succeed.
I want to see digital repack platforms develop better technology, stronger consumer safeguards, more transparent products, and experiences that attract the next generation of collectors.
I want to see established industry leaders and emerging businesses work together to raise expectations.
And I want to see companies that are doing things responsibly receive recognition for it.
That does not mean giving anyone a free pass.
Quite the opposite.
The more successful this category becomes, the greater the responsibility operators have to demonstrate that their products are trustworthy and their business practices are sound.
But we should create an environment where companies are encouraged to improve and innovate, rather than one where they are automatically placed on the defensive simply for introducing something new.
We should be setting the bar for responsible innovation, not building barriers against innovation itself.
Protecting the Hobby and Advancing the Hobby Are Not Opposing Goals
One of the biggest mistakes we can make as an industry is assuming that protecting collectors requires resisting change.
It doesn't.
We can support new technologies while demanding accountability.
We can encourage digital repacks while advocating for transparent product structures.
We can welcome new companies into the hobby while expecting them to operate responsibly.
We can acknowledge legitimate concerns about gambling-like mechanics without labeling every digital collecting experience as gambling.
And we can recognize that innovation will sometimes move faster than existing industry standards without assuming that every company operating in that environment is acting improperly.
These positions are not contradictory.
They are exactly what responsible industry leadership should look like.
The trading card industry is no longer a small, disconnected collection of hobby shops, collectors, and manufacturers.
It is an increasingly sophisticated global marketplace attracting technology companies, financial institutions, entrepreneurs, investors, and millions of participants.
With that growth comes responsibility.
But it also comes opportunity.
We cannot expect the hobby to continue growing if we discourage the very innovation that can make it more accessible, efficient, transparent, and engaging.
The Hobby Deserves a Better Conversation
I believe digital repacks can have a legitimate and valuable place in the future of trading cards.
I also believe the companies operating in this space must be prepared to meet meaningful expectations for transparency, fairness, and consumer protection.
Those two beliefs go hand in hand.
What I don't believe is that we should allow fear, selective examples, or broad characterizations to define the future of an entire industry segment.
If a company is misleading consumers, address it.
If a product lacks transparency, demand better.
If certain mechanics create legitimate consumer risks, examine them and establish appropriate safeguards.
But if a company is using technology responsibly to create a better collecting experience, we should be willing to recognize that too.
Our responsibility as an industry is not to protect the hobby from the future. It is to make sure the hobby is prepared for it.
That requires collaboration, independent standards, accountability, and a willingness to embrace progress.
The future of trading cards will undoubtedly involve more technology, not less.
And I believe that is something we should be excited about.
The question should never be whether technology belongs in the hobby.
The question should be how we ensure it strengthens the hobby for everyone.
Because at the end of the day, our goal should be the same.
A safer hobby. A smarter hobby. A stronger hobby.
And a hobby that continues to evolve for generations to come.
Nick Jarman
Founder & CEO
Certified Trading Card Association (CTCA)